If there is a vote, as a general matter I'm against bans.
most of Utley's stuff is sticks and stones, but some of those stones are thrown high and inside, and some aimed at the nuts, its a nasty brand of ball. But its just a game. I found it fun to throw back at him until he got tired of getting hit. And he generally did. Hence his several handles.
But even with his long history of lack of command, he does throw strikes from time to time. And on some stuff he's not wrong, but I find it somewhat objectionable to post in agreement, or defend his POV, unless he's playing 1 on gazillion. I don't like encouraging his darker side, which need no encouragement at all to be expressed, but I don't like bullying either. Freedom of expression is tricky stuff.
But having said that, his threat to disclose private info is in my book a suspendable offense, and he's been warned several times. IMO posting private info, without prior approval of the other party, is bannable. That's just wrong. And at this point these is no excuse for it.