Total Members Voted: 3
Voting closed: February 13, 2022, 10:41:25 PM
I think mashing the records together is a mistake.Separate and equal may be the right answer.There are AL records. NL records, MLB records, and Negro League records, recognize them all, but in a context that makes sense.
I'm all for analytical pursuits and closely examaning and comping stats. Its basically what I've done for decades. I just think dumping the Negro League stats into the MLB stats is a poor methodology and in most cases will lead to irrelevant conclusions. And Jamie Moyer was not in my opinion a Hall of Fame major league pitcher pitcher.But rather a very old one if you want to celebrate his age that's fine. So send him a card.
There really isnt a case for Moyer
Tommy John.
Jamie Moyer was similar to Tom Glavine?This is what you are going with?
Jamie Moyer was a good pitcher who had a unique back end to his career. Being great compared to other 45 year old pitchers is not the same as being great. At no time was he ever elite. He was never one of the 10 best pitchers in baseball. He does not deserve a plaque.