Happy to hear Brandon Nimmo (4.4 WAR) is an All Star. Yankee fans I am sure will be proud of Aaron Hicks' (4.7) All Star Year as well.
I'm more famliar with Hicks than Nimmo, and I think Hicks is a pretty good defensive CF with some power, aided by short-porch Y-Stadium..
I like the upside of 10D though and think he's a better hitter.
and to my knowledge you've never posted a negative post about either Hicks or Nimmo, but your barrage on 10D is pretty constant.
And rule of thumb is a quick n dirty guage of a player. and I assume in the case of Hicks his HR #s may be driving his WAR, but just a guess.