Total Members Voted: 9
Voting closed: January 19, 2021, 10:49:21 PM
My focus is on the word "most". And it's a simple question. And one I assume easily answerable. So slap away.
Fair enough. I'll put it this way. Over the years I have been friends and family with many police officers. They run the political spectrum and I occasionally have had issues with the way they think. Not one of them, though, would put up with criminal behavior and abuses of violent, out- of -control police officers and not a one would hesitate to stop such behavior thin blue line or not.And it remains a simple question for Josh. How does he know that most would behave in the manner he described?
Most police do not report the abuses of their fellow officers or interrupt them when they are doing something questionable.How do you know this?
"You have to dominate or you'll look like a bunch of jerks, you have to arrest and try people," the President told the governors in a call from the basement White House Situation Room, according to an audio recording of the call obtained by CNN."It's a movement, if you don't put it down it will get worse and worse," Trump said. "The only time its successful is when you're weak and most of you are weak."
Quote from: Yankguy1 on June 01, 2020, 08:18:52 AMMost police do not report the abuses of their fellow officers or interrupt them when they are doing something questionable.How do you know this?By the lack of reports of abuses and by watching videos in which a police officer is doing something objectionable and the others around them are not recorded as either speaking up or requesting assistance from higher up.Police disciplinary records are public record in a dozen states. There is limited accessibility in 15 more. In 23 states, they are totally obscured from the public.But we have case after case in which there has been broad corruption in a department, with no complaints filed or actions taken. In some cases, like Baltimore's, where there has been widespread corruption, the disciplinary actions and related information was secret, until the courts demanded the information.In Massachusetts, the records are also secret, but with exceptions. So, we can't see disciplinary action, but we can often see complaints against an officer and internal affairs investigations. It is the lack of the latter in the face of the former that can be especially damning.Up until 2015, Missouri had a similar standard to Maryland's, but a court ruling determined that an individual officer has no privacy interest in misconduct committed while they were working, so suddenly a ton of information became available.Minnesota holds all such information to be public, which is why we so swiftly learned of the prior issues that ex-officer Chauvin had and the failure of him to be held accountable for it.We also see it in various scenarios in which one person will direct the others to turn off their bodycams and the others in the crew will do so, without question. Nor do they turn them back on during the moments of questionable (or criminal) wrongdoing.
Yank knows decent cops. Impossible to boil these matters down to percentages. So it's better to constructively target codes of silence, rather than put people in stereotypical slots. Which makes top-down policy changes in PDs essential. Though policy would not have saved Floyd. Chauvin was in violation of his department's rules for handling suspects. Which means culture change, psych screens, etc. Expect delays. Those fixes might be cheaper than building a new police station every time something like last week happens.
Quote from: oilcan on June 01, 2020, 01:51:44 PMYank knows decent cops. Impossible to boil these matters down to percentages. So it's better to constructively target codes of silence, rather than put people in stereotypical slots. Which makes top-down policy changes in PDs essential. Though policy would not have saved Floyd. Chauvin was in violation of his department's rules for handling suspects. Which means culture change, psych screens, etc. Expect delays. Those fixes might be cheaper than building a new police station every time something like last week happens. I've got no problem with any of that.